The Great Food Blogger Cookie Swap – Recipe Time!

The Great Food Blogger Cookie Swap 2011 – the first year of this cookie swap devised by Lindsay of Love and Olive Oil and Julie of The Little Kitchen – is now coming to an end!

Today is the day we post our cookie recipes and link them all up at Lindsay’s and Julie’s link party and we wash our hands of it. But it was so much fun!

They promise us there will be another next year – I sure hope so. This one was wildly popular – I think the end count of sign-ups was over 600 and although they originally planned it to be open to the US and Canada only, it ended up being in several other countries too – I don’t have all the stats but I’m sure Lindsay or Julie will post them. This was one impressive swap!

I’ve posted about the cookie swap a couple of times before – see here and here – but here’s some quick background to my cookie swap process:

I signed up and stated my preference for naturally-sweetened goods. Because I was in Canada, Lindsay wrote to me to explain that the only other bloggers who had also specified naturally sweetened goods were in the US, and only one of them was willing to ship to Canada (the idea of the swap is that each person sends cookies to three people and gets three sets of cookies in return).

I didn’t mind, it was great just to take part!

I received my cookies from Meg at Harmonious Belly on Saturday and let me tell you, she made up for all three batches of cookies I could have received. These were amazing. I may or may not have eaten three in quick succession and called that my dinner for the night.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

They are sweet morsels of spicy, warm, honey-sweetened goodness, topped with plum preserves made from plums Meg grows in her own backyard!!!!!!! (Yes, the cookies – and the plum preserves – are deserving of all those exclamation marks).

My mom was just in love with the preserves and was ready to place an order for a whole jar (I don’t think Meg sells them in a jar – but you should Meg, you should!)

I’m not really describing these cookies properly, so I will use Meg’s words to explain them to you: “These cookies are a take-off of the Russian gingerbread cookies called pryaniki. They were adjusted by The Nourishing Gourmet, and I adjusted them further. They are sweetened with honey and filled with homemade vanilla plum preserves (the plums grew in my backyard).”

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

Yeah, I was pretty chuffed to get this pretty parcel in the mail, let me tell ya.

As for my end of the bargain, what did I send to Meg, you ask?

Vegan, naturally-sweetened Chocolate Peppermint Shortbread.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

The key with the swap was making cookies that would still taste as good on the day of arrival as the day of shipping. This was a challenge because a lot of my favourite cookies are crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside, but they would soften being in airtight containers to be shipped, and therefore would arrive just a soggy mess, or they would fall apart because they are too delicate.

Shortbread was supposed to be a little firmer, so hopefully would hold its shape and its firmness well during shipping. I wrapped each cookie in parchment paper, sealed the lot in a freezer bag and shipped in a cookie tin.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

I cut out a few star shapes but didn’t send too many to her as stars, because of the risk of the ‘arms’ falling off during shipping. I went mostly with different-shaped circles as a safer bet.

I finished with a drizzling of dark, vegan 85% cocoa chocolate, melted. You can easily make this recipe non-vegan by using regular butter and regular dark chocolate, by the way. My natural sweetener was coconut sugar.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

Here you go!

Anna’s Cookie Swap Peppermint Chocolate Shortbread Cookies

INGREDIENTS (makes 24):

1 cup Earth Balance butter (use the sticks)
3/4 cup coconut sugar
3 tsp peppermint essence
1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1/2 cup cocoa powder

1 bar vegan dark chocolate for icing


1. Preheat oven to 275 F. Cut the butter into small pieces.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

2. Cream together the butter and coconut sugar.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

3. Add the peppermint essence (you can add a drop at a time and taste, if you’re not sure how minty you want it).

4. Sift in flour and cocoa powder, mix till it is well combined and forms a ball.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

*Depending on how soft your butter was to begin with, you may want to refrigerate your dough for 10 minutes or so to set it, so it isn’t too soft when rolling out.

5. Roll out dough and cut cookies out using a cookie cutter. Place on a greased baking sheet.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

6. Bake for 20-25 minutes. Keep a keen eye on these because you won’t be able to tell how done they are by the colour, due to the cocoa powder! They will firm up a little when cooling too, so don’t overcook.

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

7. When cookies are done, put on a cooling rack and allow to cool. Meanwhile, break up the chocolate bar into small pieces in a glass bowl and place over the top of a saucepan of hot water. Keep the water on a low heat, simmering, and allow the steam to melt the chocolate.

8. Once the chocolate is melted, take a teaspoon and scoop a little chocolate up, then just move quickly from left to right, drizzling the chocolate over all the cookies. It’s supposed to look messy, so don’t worry about it being perfect! That’s the brilliance of a drizzle ;).

9. Place into the fridge to set the chocolate, then package up and ship, or – you know, for most of us – just indulge at home :).

Copyright to The Guiltless Life

Nutritional information below is per cookie if recipe makes 24:

Nutritional information courtesy of


  1. Hello love!

    Oh maybe next year I will have to do the cookie swap!

    The cookies you made look so good and I love chocolate and mint, favorite combo!

    Happy Monday! xo

  2. Sounds yummy! They look really festive with the drizzle.
    I want to try it – but I might make decidedly guiltier substitutions (butter, regular sugar) because that’s what I have 🙂

    • Hey Emily! No worries, the butter is a straight swap and you should be able to easily swap out the coconut sugar for white or brown, but I haven’t made this recipe with either so I can’t guarantee it. But I think the proportions should be about the same :).

  3. you always make such beautiful things and these cookies are no exception. yum!

  4. Hey Doll!!! Oooo anything with coconut sugar makes this girl happy!! What gorgeous cookies 🙂 I wish I had time to do cookie swaps!!! How FUN!!


  5. hoooooly yum!! I never thought to make chocolate peppermint shortbread! *dies* Those look perfect ❤

  6. I love that you post the nutrition facts. Not that this is the #1 determinant when choosing a cookie, but it is nice to know! Too bad I don’t like peppermint 😦

    • Thank you! No worries if you don’t like peppermint – leave it out for delicious rich chocolate shortbread cookies, or sub it in with another extract or flavour, like almond. Yum!

  7. A cookie swap? How fun!! Those look delightful and almost too pretty to eat! 😉

  8. So jealous, this is such a fantastic idea. I figure no one will be willing to ship to New Zealand!
    Those cookies are being made this weekend for my daughter’s end of school year party with her friends 🙂

    • Hey Ali! I actually bet you’d be surprised – tons of countries got added to the mix once the swap got up and going. There just had to be 3 people within a country for them to add it on, I bet there were some in NZ! Try it out next year, I bet you’d have a great time!

  9. I really should have participated in this… I am kicking myself now! These look rather glorious and I love the shape!

  10. Thanks for sharing you recipe at What’s In The Gunny Sack! I wanted to let you know that I featured your recipe today!


  1. […] aromas of Christmas cookies baking fill me with […]

  2. […] One of Meg’s delicious cookies thanks to the Cookie Swap! […]

  3. […] The Great Food Blogger Cookie Swap – Recipe Time! – it was so much fun taking part in this cookie swap, and my peppermint chocolate shortbread […]

  4. […] of the chocolate shortbread cookies I made for the Great Food Blogger Cookie Swap (I omitted the peppermint essence because peanut […]

  5. […] Enjoyable Blogging Community Experience: The cookie swap! (Of course! You should know by now I’m a total cookie […]

Let's chat!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: